The Wisconsin football team (6-4, 4-3 Big Ten) is back on the road this week to take on the Purdue Boilermakers (3-7, 2-5 Big Ten) in West Lafayette.
The Badgers are coming off a horrific loss that has pushed many to the breaking point with Fickell and this staff, despite the progress the team has made this season, including wins and becoming bowl-eligible again.
Purdue has been on the losing end of four straight games, but the Boilermakers won’t be an easy win, as we all thought just a few weeks ago. The Badgers are banged up, and the loss to Maryland shows this game will be no slam dunk.
Like most of the country, the BadgerNotes staff all expected the Badgers to win last week, going 0-3. Let’s try it again.
Here are the staff predictions for Week 12.
Staff predictions
• Dillon Graff
Season record: 7-3
On paper, Wisconsin should win this football game. The Badgers have the better roster, the better defense, and a Purdue opponent that’s lost four straight games. Advanced metrics favor them by a comfortable margin.
But we’ve reached the point where I’m not particularly interested in what Wisconsin should be capable of doing.
This is a team that beat Penn State and USC, then got shut out by Iowa and managed 201 yards of offense against Maryland. The week-to-week inconsistency has become so predictable that it’s practically the program’s identity.
Purdue isn’t particularly good. Its defense allows more than 417 yards per game, and Wisconsin should be able to establish something offensively against that group. But the Boilermakers have a quarterback in Ryan Browne who’s thrown for more than 2,400 yards, and Wisconsin’s secondary is dealing with injuries at a particularly inconvenient time.
Then there’s the quarterback uncertainty for Wisconsin, the offensive line that can’t seem to find any continuity, and a coaching staff that still hasn’t figured out what it wants or even thinks this offense to be.
Purdue has lost 18 straight meetings against Wisconsin. To put that drought into perspective, LeBron James hadn’t even played his first NBA regular-season game the last time the Boilermakers beat the Badgers.
Now, with Senior Day approaching in West Lafayette, Purdue has another opportunity to end that streak. And frankly, given the state of Wisconsin’s program, this feels like as good a chance as any.
I wouldn’t be remotely surprised if Wisconsin won by two touchdowns.
That’s how little confidence I have in predicting which version of this team shows up. But I’m done giving this coaching staff the benefit of the doubt. Until Wisconsin demonstrates it can consistently handle opponents it should beat, I’m not picking the Badgers simply because the numbers say I should. I genuinely cannot stomach the thought of running the Luke Fickell experiment back for a fifth year.
Prediction: Purdue 24, Wisconsin 21
• Christian Borman
Season record: 5-5
I said last week I didn’t trust the Badgers, but I let my optimism get the better of me. My faith in this team is hemorrhaging.
I want to pick Wisconsin. They should win. But they also should have beaten Maryland. The Badgers’ offensive line is beat up, and Colton Joseph will be back under center. I don’t have much faith that this running game will get going or the passing game will be overly effective.
The pressure around this team is massive. A loss to Maryland and Purdue in back-to-back weeks before playing Minnesota would be a monumental issue.
The Badgers should win this, right? I’m overthinking it. This team’s talent is just better. I think this is a game where, if it’s close, players like Mason Posa and Cooper Catalano will step up and make a play that will decide the outcome.
Ultimately, I don’t think the offense will be able to sustain drives and keep the defense on the field all game. The defensive dam will break at some point, and the offense won’t be able to pick them up.
I want to pick Wisconsin, but after going back and forth, I just can’t pull the trigger. The downward spiral continues.
Prediction: Purdue 20, Wisconsin 17
• Seamus Rohrer
Season record: 5-5
I promise you, I wanted to pick Maryland so badly last week. With each passing day, I became more and more concerned about the Terps. But by the time this prediction was due, I still couldn’t possibly wrap my head around a second dumbfounding loss to Maryland in as many seasons. I picked against my gut, and it came back to bite me.
Coaches, players and entire teams will tell you quite clearly who they are; you just have to listen. This is the same inconsistent, mistake-ridden Badgers team Fickell has presided over since 2023.
The Boilermakers offense can move the ball and put up points, and for some reason on the road defensive coordinator Mike Tressel loses any and all sense of urgency and aggression. So that’s one reason to be concerned.
Another is that Wisconsin’s offensive line is falling apart, and it might take another blow with Emerson Mandell a question mark for Saturday. This unit can’t protect, it can’t move bodies up front and most importantly, it can’t communicate; last week’s tape was awash with blown protection schemes.
Purdue, losers of four straight, doesn’t have much going for it right now, but neither do the Badgers. On paper, Wisconsin should win this game. But that was the case last week too. I’m fresh out of the benefit of the doubt with this regime.
Prediction: Purdue 24, Wisconsin 17
We appreciate you taking the time to read our work at BadgerNotes.com. Your support means the world to us and has helped us become a leading independent source for Wisconsin Badgers coverage.






You three are risking the wrath of "Patrick the Badgers Information Nazi". Brave predictions.